13 Crowd-Pleasing Easter Sunday Recipes to Wow Your Guests

🌷 Hosting an Easter gathering? Our 13 crowd-pleasing Easter Sunday recipes will help you shine as the hostess! From easy appetizers to unforgettable desserts, these dishes are simple, delicious, and perfect for celebrating with family and friends. Let these ideas bring a smile to your table and make your Easter Sunday meal stress-free and memorable!

A collage of 13 Easter Sunday recipes.

Whether you are hosting a big Easter dinner or you are bringing a dish to share, I want to help give you ideas for the big day! Holidays can be overwhelming even without involving food. Add on being the hostess or being asked to bring a specific dish (especially one you’ve never made before), and stress levels skyrocket! I want to give you some simple, tried, and true Easter Sunday recipes that are nearly foolproof. 

I want food to be the least of your worries on Easter morning so you can focus on the more important things like worshipping at church, finding good hiding spots for the Easter eggs, and visiting with family and friends! My qualifications for a good recipe are 1) it must be easy to prepare and 2) it must be DELICIOUS! The following 13 Easter Sunday recipes should give you plenty of ideas for dazzling your family and friends.

Starter Easter Sunday Recipes: Appetizers

Chunky Restaurant-Style Guacamole

Ok, so I’m from California, and guacamole goes with virtually everything. I guarantee that if you leave this out with a bowl of chips, the chunky restaurant-style guacamole will be gone in 6 and a half minutes.

Chunky guacamole served with chips.

Homemade Cilantro-Lime Salsa

This homemade cilantro-lime salsa is a beauty of a recipe because you throw everything into the food processor, blend it, and Viola! Most assuredly, someone will ask you which restaurant you bought it from, and you can proudly exclaim. “I made it myself!”

Homemade cilantro-lime salsa with fresh ingredients.

Reduced Calorie Spinach Artichoke Dip

No one will guess that this reduced calorie spinach artichoke dip has a third fewer calories. I make it with light sour cream, light cream cheese, and light mayo, and no one can tell the difference! Serve it with sourdough bread, pita chips, bagel bites, wheat crackers, or even tortilla chips.

Reduced calorie spinach artichoke dip for Easter.

Crockpot Sweet & Sour Meatballs

I love this recipe when guests come over because it sits in the Crockpot all day and makes the house smell amazing! I leave the Crockpot on warm and set out some toothpicks and POOF! The Crockpot sweet & sour meatballs are gone!

Sweet and sour meatballs for Easter Sunday.

The Main Course

Coca-Cola Glazed Holiday Ham

This Coca-Cola glazed ham may look like it took 5 hours to make, but really it is quite simple. The diamond pattern is made with simple knife cuts, and whole cloves plunged in the center. The Coca-Cola glaze is made on the stovetop and brushed on every 20 minutes. It is a stunning centerpiece for your Easter table!

Coca-Cola glazed holiday ham for Easter dinner.

Side Dishes

3 Cheese Baked Macaroni & Cheese

This 3 cheese baked macaroni & cheese is an irresistible side dish great for vegetarians and kids! It is also very easy to travel with since it is served in a typical 13×9 casserole dish. It can be made a day before the party and kept in the fridge until it needs to bake for 50 minutes.

3 cheese baked macaroni and cheese for Easter.

Shredded Hashbrown Cheesy Potatoes

I make these shredded hashbrown cheese potatoes on every holiday, birthday, celebration, or just because! Cheesy potatoes are a classic that will NEVER go out of style! These would be particularly good for Easter brunch. I make them a day ahead so the flavors have a chance to meld and make my meal planning a bit easier. Take them to a friend’s house already made, or bake them there at 350 for an hour.

Cheesy shredded hashbrown potatoes for Easter.

Apple Blue Cheese Salad

Traditionally, apple and pork pair really well together. If you are making a ham for Easter dinner, I would BEG you to make this salad to go with it! I really love salad, all kinds of salad, but I think this apple blue cheese salad may top my list! Store your lettuce and dressing separately, and toss it all together with the blue cheese when dinner is served. I’m all about having fewer headaches and more fun!

Apple blue cheese salad for Easter Sunday

Vegetables

Oven Roasted Brussel Sprouts

Do you have 10 minutes? Then you can make these oven roasted brussel sprouts! The rich, nutty flavor perfectly compliments a ham or roast beef. I don’t recommend making these ahead and traveling with them unless your drive is under 10 minutes. They are served best straight out of the oven. But if the hostess doesn’t mind, you could easily bake these at her house if she’ll let you borrow a knife and cookie sheet!

Oven roasted brussel sprouts for Easter dinner.

Apple, Broccoli, & Horseradish Slaw

This is a great salad to serve if you are trying to keep things on the healthier side. The horseradish is mild but adds just the right amount of kick. The other great thing about this slaw is that the longer it sits, the better it gets! Make this apple, broccoli, & horseradish slaw in the morning and serve it in the afternoon. It’s perfect to travel with and adds a nice bit of crunch to the Easter table.

Apple, broccoli, and horseradish slaw for Easter.

Desserts

Carrot & Raisin Cream Cheese Cupcakes

This is a traditional carrot cake recipe that I took the liberty of changing into cupcakes. I’m so glad I did because they were a cinch to serve! The carrot & raisin cream cheese cupcakes also helped with portion control, though I may or may not have helped myself to more than one… or two. But if you have your heart set on a cake, just use the same recipe and pull out the 9″ cake pans!

Carrot and raisin cream cheese cupcakes for Easter.

Easter M&M Rice Krispie Treats

These are a kid’s favorite! Be careful not to leave too many out at once, or they’ll be gone! If you have been invited to a friend’s house and asked to bring dessert, I would recommend these M&M Rice Krispie treats. No baking is required, and they’re really budget-friendly for a large group. You can add M&Ms of any color and size to dazzle your guests. They are also beautiful, wrapped in cellophane and stuffed in an Easter basket.

Easter M&M Rice Krispie treats decorated for Easter.

Pistachio & Coconut Pudding Cake

There are only 4 steps to this refreshing pistachio & coconut pudding cake! The pistachio pudding in both the cake and frosting gives the cake a tint of green, perfect for a spring dessert. The pistachios also give a nice crunch to the velvety smooth pudding. This is the perfect light dessert after a heavier holiday meal.

Pistachio & coconut pudding cake perfect for Easter Sunday.

Well, folks, that’s a wrap! I think I’ve got you prepped and prepared with these Easter Sunday recipes!

Dan and Heidi celebrate Easter Sunday together.

My husband, my three little munchkins, and I wish you a Happy Easter, or as we say in our house, Resurrection Sunday! May you be blessed on this joyous holiday!

Pinterest graphic of 13 Easter Sunday recipes.

Heidi Davison

Head Baker & Owner

Hi, I'm Heidi, Head Baker and Owner of Heidi's Bakery in Knoxville, TN.

What began as a blog to share family recipes has become a thriving bakery, thanks to community support.
Many recipes here are from my family’s cookbook. Give them a try and leave a comment below!

Heidi Davison the Owner of Heidis Bakery

Leave the first comment